In this episode of the Pipeliners Podcast, host Russel Treat is joined by Dr. Martha Acosta to discuss the idea of building safety capacity, as well as her book, Safety Capacity, during the 2025 API Pipeline Conference in Austin, Texas.
Building Safety Capacity Show Notes, Links, and Insider Terms
- Dr. Martha Acosta is an author and leadership expert and advisor in Human and Organizational Learning who helps leaders build resilient, high-performing organizations by navigating the complexity of human systems across strategy, culture, and operations. Connect with Dr. Martha Acosta on LinkedIn.
- Safety Capacity: Leadership Practices for Failing Safely, presents six essential leadership practices that help safety leaders build organizational capacity to absorb failure, prevent catastrophe, and enable learning, innovation, and resilience in high-risk work environments.
- API (American Petroleum Institute) represents all segments of America’s natural gas and oil industry. API has developed more than 800 standards to enhance operational and environmental safety, efficiency, and sustainability.
- Safety Capacity: The ability of an organization to absorb failures—both by preventing harmful consequences and by learning from the unexpected. It’s about creating systems that are resilient and adaptable when things don’t go as planned.
- HOP (Human and Organizational Performance): A safety and performance philosophy emphasizing that human error is normal and that systems must be designed to manage and learn from those errors.
- HPI (Human Performance Improvement): A concept borrowed from the nuclear industry, focused on understanding that errors are inevitable and improving systems by learning from how work is actually performed by people.
- Learning Teams: A structured approach to learning from frontline workers by gathering their experiences and insights to identify risks, hazards, and opportunities for system improvements.
- Leadership Capacity: The ability of organizational leaders to create meaning, foster shared understanding, and support safe and effective performance. It also includes the intentional act of creating space for true leadership activities like learning and engaging with workers.
- Organizational Capacity: Refers to an organization’s overall ability to reconcile safety and innovation—managing risk while adapting to new challenges and integrating learning into practice.
- Process Safety: A discipline that focuses on preventing unintentional releases of chemicals, energy, or other hazardous substances in industrial processes, particularly important in pipeline operations.
- Critical Thinking: A learned skill necessary for effective leadership and decision-making. It includes evaluating assumptions, analyzing information, and considering the implications of changes.
- Decision-Making Process: A formalized method leaders can use to ensure informed, inclusive, and transparent decisions. Includes identifying assumptions, gathering inputs, and clarifying decision-makers.
- Procedure: A documented set of instructions meant to guide consistent, safe operations. However, rigid adherence without understanding context or questioning assumptions can be problematic.
- Assumptions: Beliefs or conditions taken as true when planning or performing work. Recognizing and reevaluating them is crucial to maintaining safety and performance as environments change.
- System Work: The organizational effort needed when a routine failure occurs in a familiar task, indicating that some underlying system conditions may have changed or broken down.
- Consequence Management: The aspect of safety capacity focused on reducing or eliminating the harmful effects of a failure or incident.
- Absorb (Failure): In this context, means both mitigating the impact of a failure (like a safety pad cushions a fall) and integrating what is learned from it into organizational knowledge.
Building Safety Capacity Full Episode Transcript
Russel Treat: Welcome to the “Pipeliners Podcast,” episode 388, sponsored by the American Petroleum Institute, driving safety, environmental protection, and sustainability across the natural gas and oil industry through world-class standards and safety programs.
Since its formation as a standards-setting organization in 1919, API has developed more than 800 standards to enhance industry operations worldwide. Find out more about API at api.org.
[music]
Announcer: The Pipeliners Podcast, where professionals, bubba geeks, and industry insiders share their knowledge and experience about technology, projects, and pipeline operations.
Now your host, Russel Treat.
Russel: Thanks for listening to the Pipeliners Podcast. I appreciate you taking the time. To show the appreciation, we give away a YETI tumbler with a cool Pipeliners Podcast logo to one listener every week. This week, the winner is Devin Bishop with ONEOK. Congratulations, Devin. Your YETI is on its way. To learn how you can win this prize, stick around till the end of the episode.
This week, we speak with Dr. Martha Acosta, author of “Safety Capacity” and keynote speaker at the recent API Pipeline Conference.
We’re here at the 2025 API Pipeline Conference in Austin, Texas. I’m here with Dr. Martha Acosta, who is our keynote speaker this morning. She wrote a book on safety capacity which I read. It’s awesome. I recommend it. I’d like to, first, say welcome to the Pipeliners Podcast.
Dr. Martha Acosta: Thank you.
Russel: I’d like to ask you, what caused you to write a book on safety capacity?
Dr. Acosta: I was involved in the creation of the concept of HOP early on, with Todd Conklin, where we took HPI from the nuclear power industry and applied it to the nuclear defense industry.
Russel: HPI?
Dr. Acosta: HPI, human performance improvement. The focus there — it was a really important focus — was that we recognize that you couldn’t fix the worker, that error is normal, that everybody makes mistakes, that even the most expert people make the most mistakes. In fact, they make the craziest mistakes because they know how to work around the system to get things done.
There was a big focus on the worker and learning with the worker. I realized that we’d hit a point where we needed to look to the organization and we needed to look to leaders.
People like Bob Edwards and Andy Baker, who were doing great work rolling out learning teams and really learning from the worker to identify how do we better manage risk, identify hazards, create barriers to those hazards, they were finding that, at some point, taking what you learned from the worker needed to be institutionalized into the organization. Leaders really needed to do that.
This book is a way of starting to understand how leaders build the systems that keep people safe.
Russel: There was a couple of key things I took away from the book. I’ll start with this. This is a belief of mine before I read your book. Leadership is not direction. Leadership is seeking to understand.
Your book really underscores that safety capacity is all about working with the people doing the work and seeking to understand what are they doing and why are they doing it that way and so forth. You would think that would be instinctive, but I don’t know that it is.
You made a really good point in your presentation that when you get a job in a pipeline company as a manager, you don’t start with this. You start with “Here’s your HR manual. Here’s your procedures manual. Here’s your roles and responsibilities and all this stuff,” which is not leadership.
Dr. Acosta: Which is not the same thing.
Russel: It’s something else. I don’t know what you call it, but it’s something else.
Dr. Acosta: I would take what you said and take it a little bit further and say that leaders…First, I’ll say the organizations are systems of meaning. Nobody really does anything unless it’s meaningful. The influence that leaders make, the way that they tell people what their goals are and what their work is and what their roles and responsibilities are, ultimately, that’s meaning and meaningful.
What leaders are doing and why they need to seek to understand is because they need to create a meaningful workplace for people where that meaning is shared between the leaders and the workers and even the partners in the organization, everybody who has a shared purpose towards achieving something.
Russel: Let me ask this question. How would you define safety capacity?
Dr. Acosta: I define safety capacity as an organization’s ability to absorb failures and recognizing that failure is something different from what we think about it as the bad outcome. Failure is just the unexpected and the unwanted occurrence that happens on a regular basis.
Russel: It’s any outcome that’s not the outcome you were looking for.
Dr. Acosta: Exactly.
Russel: This is something I thought was really interesting. Again, I didn’t get it out of the book, but I got it out of your presentation today. You talked a little bit about needing to understand there’s different classes of failures.
You need to understand, when I’m experimenting, I’m trying something new, I need to set it up so those failures are learning events. They’re opportunity for me to get more context and learn more. On the other hand, when I’m actually doing the work that matters, those failures are consequential and need to be pounced on.
Dr. Acosta: Those are indicators that there’s a problem in a system. If you have routine regular work where you have a very long experience that if you do this, then this will happen and that doesn’t happen, that means that something major has changed and you have to do some real system work.
Russel: One of the other things you talked about in your book is this idea of leadership capacity. That’s really interesting. A lot of times, when we find ourselves in roles as a leader, a lot of what we’re doing is not leadership. To create the room to do that which is leadership requires a real level of intentionality.
Leadership is about learning and about enrolling. It’s about enrolling people in the meaning and about learning about what they’re doing and how it impacts the meaning.
Dr. Acosta: Learning and innovation is an important part of performance. I don’t want to get rid of the idea that leaders are there to drive and create performance towards a shared goal for the organization. Organizations need to perform. They need to meet their goals. They need to make money. That’s what leaders are there for.
You recognize that saying, “I told you to do this way” and exercising your authority…Anybody who’s been a leader knows that that isn’t effective. You really need to use the full potential of everybody that’s in your organization to realize that performance and those gains together.
Russel: One of the reasons that the breakthrough ideas come from people that are outsiders or newcomers is they’re not infected…
Dr. Acosta: [laughs]
Russel: …to use a word, with “This is the way it’s done here.” There’s a need for that trade-off, and particularly with pipelining because what we do is so consequential and process safety is so important.
Our systems live in people’s backyards, so our need for safety is exceedingly high. Whenever we’re making change or we’re having risk, we need to be thoughtful and careful about it, but we also need to innovate. Those two things are in conflict with one another.
You address that a bit in what you call organizational capacity. How do you reconcile that conflict in an organization between “We do it this way because it’s safe and it gets us where we need to go” versus “We need to think and innovate and try something new”?
Dr. Acosta: I would question the assumption that we do it this way because it’s safe. It was safe once. Is it always safe to do it that way? Where are we working that might have changes in what the hazards are or there are assumptions that we made that are no longer true? One of the most dangerous kinds of work everywhere is digging a hole. Digging a hole is incredibly dangerous.
Russel: It is…
Dr. Acosta: [laughs]
Russel: …particularly in our business.
Dr. Acosta: It’s really important to recognize that you have all kinds of conditions when digging a hole, in that the operator is only going to fully understand those conditions once they break ground. Then they need to be able to adapt to that.
The reason why I use the word “absorb” is because it has a dual meaning. There’s the absorb where you fall into a pad and that pad absorbs your fall and makes sure that you don’t break anything, but there’s also the sense of absorb in learning.
Safety capacity has both of those senses, where we want to make sure that a failure doesn’t have a bad consequence and the energy of that failure is absorbed in a way that you don’t get hurt, but it’s also we want to be able to learn and absorb and integrate into our organizational knowledge what we learn from that failure.
Russel: I want to back up because you said something that’s really deep. That is, we got to be careful about what are the assumptions that we made to get to this way of doing things. Are they still correct?
One of the things that I’m a big believer in this, whenever you’re putting together any kind of plan, you have to start with what assumptions you’re making. Then you need to keep those assumptions top of mind. That’s very challenging, even for an individual. It’s much more challenging for an organization.
When things change, you need to go back and say, “Does that impact our assumptions? If it does, then what?” That’s what you’re getting at, is how do I keep those assumptions that undergird how I do things top of mind.
Dr. Acosta: Critical thinking and good decision-making do not happen by accident. One of the tools that leaders have is processes and procedures. We know, those of us who’ve worked in regulated industries, that procedures can be problematic for us, especially if we think that if we do a procedure a certain way, we’re going to be safe every time.
Those practices, like recognizing your assumptions, questioning them, and keeping them top of mind as you move forward and plan work, is very important.
Having a decision-making process where you know who’s going to be the decider, you know where your inputs are going to be, and you’re very clear about where your information is going to come from that’s ultimately going to inform that decision is really important.
Those two things, for some reason, in my experience, we just expect, “There are good decision-makers, and there are good critical thinkers.” Uh-uh. No one’s born that way.
Russel: No. It’s a learned behavior.
Dr. Acosta: It really is a learned skill.
Russel: Absolutely.
Dr. Acosta: We have to think about what skills we want to promote in our organizations that make us better.
Russel: We also tend to think that, “These people with this education and these roles, they’re the critical thinkers.” The reality is we’re all critical thinkers. Many of us are doing that in an unconscious way. That’s where risk comes from.
I have a firm belief that most of the innovation we need is close to where the work’s performed. It’s not going to come from an engineer or a manager or a leader. It’s going to come from the people doing the work. You need organizational systems that will get that knowledge where it needs to go.
That leads to another question. The other question is, what is psychological capacity? That’s key here, right?
Dr. Acosta: That’s really huge. It’s really key. On one level, I could simply say one aspect of it is psychological safety. In order to engage in critical thinking, you have to be willing to challenge assumptions. You have to be willing to contradict other people. You have to bring information that your boss doesn’t want to hear forward and that sort of thing.
Also, it’s a recognition and a management of our emotions because our emotions are a big part of this. Why do we jump to blame in a failure? It’s not because we’re bad people. It’s because that is an emotional defense. That’s an ego defense.
We are separating ourselves from that painful thing. Either we’re blaming others, or even, sometimes, we’re blaming ourselves. It’s a way of making sense of something that is emotionally difficult. Over and over again, we know that you can’t actually make good decisions without emotions. Yet emotions are the basis of a lot of biases. We have to balance those two things.
Russel: I could do a whole series of podcasts on this conversation. I’m a pretty stereotypical engineer. In my youth, I was a pretty hardcore stereotypical engineer. What I mean by that is…There’s right. There’s wrong. These are the boundaries. We don’t get outside the boundaries.
While that’s very effective when I’m working on an engineering problem, it’s exceedingly ineffective when I’m working on a people problem. What I’ve had to learn is…
The way I language this is it’s like I need to wonder. Like, “Why are you doing it that way?” Not like, “You’re wrong or right,” but just like, “Why? Really, for real, why? Why do I think this thing? Why am I holding that assumption? Why am I using this approach? Why am I taking that shortcut? Whatever that is, whatever that is, just wondering about the why.
If you can get an organization that can wonder about the why…Why did that not work? Why did that work? If you can wonder about the why as an organization, out of that comes real opportunity for improvement. Significant. You get transformational improvement out of that.
Dr. Acosta: In dealing with human systems, we’re always experimenting a little bit. We’re always discovering and creating new knowledge. All human systems are complex systems. Every instance of a human interaction is going to be somewhat different.
There’s so many factors, nested systems that are involved in it, perceptions, emotions, interactions, history, all of that sort of thing. It’s not that it’s not understandable. It’s just that you don’t find the right answer and then just stick with that right answer.
I was married to a physicist for a long time. We had long arguments about positivism and relativism…
Russel: [laughs]
Dr. Acosta: …and all of this stuff.
Russel: The deeper the science…
Dr. Acosta: [laughs]
Russel: …the closer the psychological and the physical become.
Dr. Acosta: Exactly.
Russel: So true.
Dr. Acosta: We have to find that balance. Of course we have to have some certainty and build some certainty for people to help them feel like what they do is going to have some impact and they’re going to get an outcome that they want, but we also need to enjoy, if that’s possible, some of the uncertainty and see the possibility in it.
That’s why the organizational side of the equation, the organizational capacity, is really all about strategy.
Russel: It’s really holding a childlike wonder. What children do, particularly boys, they like to take things apart, like to understand how they work. They might try to put them back together, but they love to take things apart.
That’s really what we’re called to do here. We need to consistently go and take things apart, even if it’s something we took apart before. If we hadn’t taken it apart in a while, we might learn something new.
This raises my last question for you. What do we as an industry, as pipeliners, what do we need to do to make this move towards creating safety capacity?
Dr. Acosta: It has to happen at multiple levels. People, at the strategic level, really need to be thinking about how their strategy is going to be executed and how their strategic decisions are going to impact operations and impact culture and then how do operations and culture, people, need to adapt to make sure that that strategy moves forward.
The strategy needs to be conveyed in a way that people understand it and can adopt that purpose and see what it means to them. People need to be able to say, “Based on the strategy, I know how to make a good decision. I know what my role is. I know what I might need to do differently or pay attention to in order to make the strategy work.”
Strategy, I recognize, happens on a high floor with a bunch of people that are running spreadsheets and modeling stuff and trying out all of this. It needs to be that way to drive good decision-making, but it needs to really go further.
On the psychological side, leaders need to learn how to pay attention to their own emotions. They need to learn how to emotionally regulate a little bit better. They need to develop empathy.
Russel: I would tell you what I find. When you look at the senior leadership — I’m talking VPs and up — typically, those guys get that. When I say, “Guys,” I mean ladies and men. Those people get it.
It’s at that level where you’re transitioning out of being an engineer and you’re moving into being an executive — it’s the director/manager level — where that exists more. The real challenge is we really need to resource people at that level to learn leadership skills in a new way. That would be my take.
Dr. Acosta: Leadership development is a really important function of the organization. I call those people the frozen middle. The thing is that they are stuck in a really difficult situation. They have a view to strategy, but they don’t necessarily have a lot of influence on strategy.
They have an understanding of the operations, but they no longer are directing, directly, operations. They’re separated from the people, but they’re the translators. When you’re translating meaning, you’re going to run into a lot of paradoxes.
Russel: And a lot of resistance.
Dr. Acosta: And a lot of resistance.
Russel: You’re going to need to do a lot of education. You’re going to need to do it over and over again. For me, just speaking for myself, what doesn’t work is you can’t force people to learn it. They got to want to. They got to understand to want to.
It’s really interesting. I can so relate to that. For me, it speaks loudly to like my own career path and my own evolvement as a leader and so forth.
Dr. Acosta: I’ve developed thousands of leaders. I’ve run thousands of programs — not thousands — hundreds of programs for leaders. I know that they get it when they say, “My wife and my kids, my spouse and my kids are really responding…”
Russel: [laughs]
Dr. Acosta: “…to me doing this differently.”
Russel: Leadership starts in the home.
Dr. Acosta: I know.
Russel: [laughs]
Dr. Acosta: When they recognize that these interpersonal skills are incredibly helpful in helping them solve problems, move forward, meet their ambitions…
Russel: It’s so true.
Dr. Acosta: …make their kids happy [laughs] …
Russel: I’ve done a lot of leadership training, some in the military when I was young. I hated it because I didn’t want to do leadership training. I wanted to build things. I just wasn’t clear that you needed people to build things. You could spend a lot of time unpacking that.
Fundamentally, as an industry, we’re really committed to process safety. We’re really committed to having it transform how we work and operate and have it transform culture. We’re…I don’t want to say, “Struggling.” We’re working on what are the resistance points and how do we break through them.
From my standpoint, I think you have a lot of great information in your book.
Dr. Acosta: Thank you.
Russel: I thought you did a great presentation. Hopefully, people will listen to this, and they’ll get your book. It’s a pretty easy read. It’s got a lot of meat in it.
Dr. Acosta: Thanks very much.
Russel: Thanks for being on the podcast.
Dr. Acosta: Absolutely. This was a great time. It’s great to talk to someone who automatically gets it. [laughs]
Russel: I should share with the listeners that when we got on the phone and we were comparing notes, we very quickly strayed off of what we were there to talk about and started talking about how do you do…We actually got into the meat of it real quick.
Dr. Acosta: Absolutely.
Russel: Anyways, great to have you here.
Dr. Acosta: Thank you so much. I appreciate it.
Russel: I hope you enjoyed this week’s episode of the Pipeliners Podcast and our conversation with Dr. Acosta. Just a reminder before you go, you should register to win our Pipeliners Podcast YETI tumbler. Just visit pipelinepodcastnetwork.com/win and enter yourself in the drawing.
[background music]
Russel: If you’d like to support us, best way to do that is to leave us a review. You can do that wherever you listen. If you have ideas, questions, or topics you’d be interested in, please let me know on the Contact Us page at pipelinepodcastnetwork.com, or reach out to me on LinkedIn. Thanks for listening. I’ll talk to you next week.
[music]



